How do I add EVERNOTE to the "Open with..." context menu in Apple Mail

I am NOT looking for the "Open with..." menu in Finder. That's fine for me.

When I right-click PDF email attachments in Apple Mail it won't show me "Evernote" as an option. The Finder menu does, but not the one in Apple Mail. I did reset the LaunchService but it didn't change anything.

It's weird because I always read that the "open With..." in Finder and Mail should be the same, but for me they definitely are not.

Any idea someone? Thanks.

Reiner

Mac OS X 10.10.01 on MacBook Pro Retina 15"